Comments on: A guy in VA gave $19K of jewelry to his girlfriend. She is out of town and he took it back? Crime or not? http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/ For the Best Deals on Music Boxes, Jewelry Boxes, Parts and Accessories Tue, 08 Dec 2009 15:08:07 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: Holister http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/comment-page-1/#comment-591 Holister Sun, 15 Mar 2009 18:09:16 +0000 http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/#comment-591 nope its not considerd a gift if he dosent say so and if he has the rciepts nothing she can realy do besides if she dosent like the guy why worry about the jewlery if shes only worried about the jewles shes a gold diggin thief and needs to be banished from societys ranks nope its not considerd a gift if he dosent say so and if he has the rciepts nothing she can realy do besides if she dosent like the guy why worry about the jewlery if shes only worried about the jewles shes a gold diggin thief and needs to be banished from societys ranks ]]> By: kissmybum http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/comment-page-1/#comment-590 kissmybum Sun, 15 Mar 2009 02:21:11 +0000 http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/#comment-590 Sounds more like a civil suit. good luck Sounds more like a civil suit.

good luck

]]> By: CrazyGypsy http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/comment-page-1/#comment-589 CrazyGypsy Sat, 14 Mar 2009 08:46:06 +0000 http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/#comment-589 It is a felony -- grand theft. He may not have his life ruined since he might be able to lie his way out of it -- but you'd be surprised how hard it can be to lie and get away with it. Had he ever told anyone he gave the jewelry to her? Did she? Lots of ways to get caught -- for example, you know about it, so you might testify against him. If he told you, who else did he tell? etc. etc. He should just give it back to her and then he'll be able to sleep better. It is a felony — grand theft.

He may not have his life ruined since he might be able to lie his way out of it — but you’d be surprised how hard it can be to lie and get away with it. Had he ever told anyone he gave the jewelry to her? Did she? Lots of ways to get caught — for example, you know about it, so you might testify against him. If he told you, who else did he tell? etc. etc. He should just give it back to her and then he’ll be able to sleep better.

]]> By: diogenese19348 http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/comment-page-1/#comment-588 diogenese19348 Wed, 11 Mar 2009 02:02:14 +0000 http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/#comment-588 There was no breaking and entering, he has the receipts, and there is no written proof of the gifting. No grounds for criminal charges. Worst he is looking at is breach of promise which is a civil suit. There was no breaking and entering, he has the receipts, and there is no written proof of the gifting.

No grounds for criminal charges.

Worst he is looking at is breach of promise which is a civil suit.

]]> By: Takfam http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/comment-page-1/#comment-587 Takfam Sun, 08 Mar 2009 13:23:32 +0000 http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/#comment-587 She can't prove any of it. Furthermore, she gave him a key to her house. Its not burglary if you trust someone and they violate that trust. She can’t prove any of it. Furthermore, she gave him a key to her house. Its not burglary if you trust someone and they violate that trust. ]]> By: greencoke http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/comment-page-1/#comment-586 greencoke Thu, 05 Mar 2009 14:09:50 +0000 http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/#comment-586 If he gave it to her then it is now her jewely. So it is a crime for him to take it back. And that would be a felony since the jewely is worlth so much. If he gave it to her then it is now her jewely. So it is a crime for him to take it back.

And that would be a felony since the jewely is worlth so much.

]]> By: Lysa F http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/comment-page-1/#comment-585 Lysa F Mon, 02 Mar 2009 18:46:05 +0000 http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/#comment-585 It is a crime because he gave those things as gifts. He has no right to them since they are not his property. The girlfriend could have thrown the jewelery into the ocean and he couldn't do anything about it. He can go to jail for burglary. It is a crime because he gave those things as gifts. He has no right to them since they are not his property. The girlfriend could have thrown the jewelery into the ocean and he couldn’t do anything about it.

He can go to jail for burglary.

]]> By: jimvalentinojr http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/comment-page-1/#comment-584 jimvalentinojr Sun, 01 Mar 2009 08:13:40 +0000 http://www.musicboxhq.com/a-guy-in-va-gave-19k-of-jewelry-to-his-girlfriend-she-is-out-of-town-and-he-took-it-back-crime-or-not/#comment-584 If he has the reciepts for and possession of the jewelry, then it is her word against his about who actually owns them. (Unless there are witnesses on either side.) If he admits in court that he gave them to her as a gift, then he is screwed. Otherwise it is a stalemate, and he is safe. If he has the reciepts for and possession of the jewelry, then it is her word against his about who actually owns them. (Unless there are witnesses on either side.)

If he admits in court that he gave them to her as a gift, then he is screwed. Otherwise it is a stalemate, and he is safe.

]]>